In his November 13 speech to the Federalist Society, Secretary of State Marco Rubio defended President Donald Trump’s sanctions against the International Criminal Court (ICC), calling it “fake and illegitimate.” He denounced it as “an unelected world tribunal” claiming authority over sovereign nations, including those that “never signed up for it.”
Yet in March 2022, then-Senator Rubio co-sponsored a Senate resolution that described the ICC as a tribunal that “seeks to uphold the rule of law” by investigating and trying individuals accused of the gravest international crimes. The resolution encouraged ICC member states to petition the court to investigate Russian war crimes in Ukraine — even though Russia, like the United States and Israel, is not a party to the court’s founding treaty.
Both Ukraine and the State of Palestine, a United Nations non-member observer state, accepted ICC jurisdiction over crimes committed on their territories. In the Israeli cases, the court stated that Israel’s consent was not required because the alleged crimes occurred on Palestinian territory.
But after the ICC issued arrest warrants against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former defense minister Yoav Gallant for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza, the Trump administration responded with sanctions. President Trump’s February 2025 executive order authorizing those sanctions explicitly cited the warrants.
When a court’s legitimacy depends on whether it targets an adversary or an ally, international justice ceases to be a principle to uphold. Instead, it becomes just another political tool.
Terry Hansen is a retired educator. He lives in Milwaukee.
